Application Essay For Graphic Design Graphic Design College Admission Essay Admissions Essay Graduate School Proper College Admission Essay Heading College Admission Essay Heading Graduate Admission Essay Heading Heading On Admission Essay Admission Essay Harvard Admission Essay For Harvard Application Essay For Harvard University Funny Harvard Admission Essay Jfk Harvard Admission Essay Harvard Llm Admission Essay Harvard Mba Admission Essay Harvard Admission Essay Prompt Rivers Cuomo Admission Essay Harvard Admission Essay To Harvard Kennedy#39s Admission Essay To Harvard Rivers Cuomo Admission Essay To Harvard Harvard University Admission Essay Prompt College Application Essay How Long Common Application Essay How Long Should It Be How Long Should Admission Essay Be Admission Essay How To Application Essay How To Application Essay How To Start College Admission Essay How To Application Essay To A University Admission Essay To Business School Admission Essay For Baylor University Admission Essay Cornell Admissions Essay Csu Admission Essay To Dental School Admission Essay For Dental Hygiene Admission Essay Ethical Dilemma Admission Essay For Duke Admission Essay Graphic Design Admissions Essay To Fidm Admission Essay For Graduate School Admission Essay For Mba Admission Essay Heading Admission Essay For Howard Admission Essay Mph Admissions Essay To Nursing Application Essay To Nyu Admission Essay Prompts Admission Essay Psychology Admission Essay Physical Therapy Admission Essay For Rutgers Admission Essay International Relations Admission Essay To Stanford College Application Essay How To Start Admission Essay Teacher Admissions Essay Ucf Admission Essay For Usf Admission Essay For Vcu College Application Essay How To Write Admission Essay Yale Nyu Admissions Essay Hugh Gallagher College Admissions Essay Hugh Gallagher Common Application Essay Help Uc Application Essay Help Ib Application Essay Help College Application Essay Help Online Study Abroad Application Essay Help Nyc Doe Application Essay Help Internship Application Essay Help Mba Application Essay Help Medical School Application Essay Help Scholarship Application Essay Help Nyc Teacher Application Essay Help College Application Essay Heading Heading For Application Essay Graduate School Application Essay Heading Heading On Application Essay Proper College Application Essay Heading Scholarship Application Essay Heading College Admission Essay Introduction Graduate Admission Essay Introduction Admissions Essay Art School Admissions Essay Blog Admission Essay College Admission Essay Computer Science Admission Essay Carnegie Mellon Admission Essay For Culinary School Admission Essay For Dental School Admission Essay For University Admission Essay Goals Admission Essay How Long Admission Essay Hooks Admission Essay For Howard University Admission Essay Ivy League Admission Essay For New York University Admission Essay For Njcu Admission Essay Occupational Therapy Admission Essay For Odu Admission Essay For Ohio State University Admission Essay Proofreading Admission Essay Public Health Admission Essay Public Administration Application Essay Quotes Admission Essay For Radiology Admission Essay Social Work Admission Essay To Mba Admission Essay Uf Admission Essay Word Limit College Application Essay Prompts 2011 College Application Essay Thesis Statement Application Essay For Internship Appic Internship Application Essay Essay Applying For Internship How To Write An Application Essay For Internship Moma Internship Application Essay Museum Internship Application Essay Marketing Internship Application Essay Nursing Internship Application Essay Psychology Internship Application Essay Research Internship Application Essay Science Internship Application Essay Teaching Internship Application Essay Ib Application Essay 2012 Student Application Essay For Ib Essay For Ib Application Pre Ib Application Essay College Admission Essay Prompts 2012 College Admission Essay By Hugh Gallagher College Admissions Essay Blog College Admissions Essay Body College Admissions Essays Brown College Admission Essay Conclusion College Admission Essay Double Space College Admission Essay Don#39ts College Admissions Essay Diabetes College Admission Essay Funny College Admission Essay For Uf College Admission Essay Humor College Admission Essay How Long College Admission Essay Length College Admission Essay Mistakes College Admission Essay Music College Application Essay Prompts Nyu College Admission Essay Narrative College Admission Essay On Nursing College Admission Essay On Music College Admission Essays On Yourself College Admission Essay Prompt College Admission Essay Pharmacy College Admission Essay Quote College Admissions Essay Religion College Admission Essay Stanford Which College Entrance Essay Thesis Statement Is The Most Appropriately Focused College Application Essay Prompts Texas College Admission Essay Texas College Admissions Essay Ucf College Admission Essay Writing Prompts College Entrance Essay Writing Prompts College Admission Essay Word Limit College Application Essay Prompts New York University College Application Essay Art Institute Art Institute Of Chicago Admission Essay Admission Essay For Art Institute Application Essay For Art Institute Of Pittsburgh Art Institute Of California Admission Essay Essay For Admission To Art Institute Admission Essay Why I Want To Be A Nurse College Admission Essays For Criminal Justice Jmu Admissions Essay Prompt Juilliard Application Essay Johns Hopkins Application Essay 2012 Johns Hopkins Admission Essay Johns Hopkins Admission Essay Prompt Johns Hopkins Admissions Essays Worked Journalism Admission Essays Journalism Application Essay Journalism School Admission Essay Journalism College Admission Essays Jfk Admission Essay Jfk Application Essay Kellogg Admission Essays Kellogg Admissions Essays 2010 Kellogg Admissions Essays 2012 Kellogg Admissions Essays 2013 Kellogg Admissions Essays 2011 Kellogg Mba Admission Essay Kenyon Application Essay Kenyon College Admission Essay Kutztown Application Essay Ksu Admission Essay Ksu Application Essay Admission Essay Length Common Application Essay Length 2011 Graduate School Admission Essay Length Common Application Essay Length Limit Length Of Admission Essay Admission Essay Law School Best Law School Admission Essay Admission Essay For Law School Good Law School Admission Essay Harvard Law School Admission Essay Law School Admission Essay Length Yale Law School Admission Essay Admission Essay Low Gpa Admission Essays About Leadership College Admission Essay About Leadership College Admission Essay Leadership Mba Admission Leadership Essay Admission Essay For Lsu Application Essay For Lsu Harvard Law Admission Essay Nus Law Admission Essay Admission Essay To Law School Common Application Essay Length College Application Essay Length Common Application Essay Length 2012 Ut Application Essay Length Uc Application Essay Length Texas Application Essay Length Secondary Application Essay Length Common App Essay Length 2012 Common App Essay Length 2013 Ut Austin Application Essay Length Average College Application Essay Length Aampm Application Essay Length Texas Aampm Application Essay Length Common Application Activity Essay Length Common App Essay Ideal Length Tamu Application Essay Length Transfer Application Essay Length Texas Common Application Essay Length The Common Application Essay Length Apply Texas Application Essay Length University Of Texas Application Essay Length Common Application Transfer Essay Length Admissions Essay Leadership Application Essay For Leadership College Application Essay About Leadership College Application Essay Leadership Mba Application Essay Leadership Admission Essay On Leadership College Application Essay On Leadership Admitted Mba Essays Stanford Admission Essays Mba Application Essay For Mba Admission Essay For Business School Mba Admission Application Essay Mba Admission Essay Analysis Bu Mba Admission Essay Mba Admission Essay Consultant Mba Admission Essay Columbia Mba College Admission Essay Cambridge Mba Admission Essay Mba Admission Essay Editing Executive Mba Admission Essay Mba Admission Essay Help Hkust Mba Admission Essay Essay For Admission In Mba Mit Mba Admission Essay My Mba Admission Essay Nus Mba Admission Essay Nyu Mba Admission Essay Essay On Mba Admission Mba Admission Essay Pdf Personal Essay Mba Admission Mba Admission Essay Writing Service Mba Admission Essay Writer Wharton Mba Admission Essay Yale Mba Admission Essay Secondary Application Essay Medical School Best Medical School Admission Essay Admission Essay For Medical School Harvard Medical School Admission Essay Admission Essay To Medical School Mit Admission Essay Prompt Mit Admission Essay 2012 Mit Admission Essay 2013 Mit College Admission Essay Admission Essay For Mit Mit Graduate Admission Essay Mit Sloan Admission Essay Admission Essay For Msw Admission Essay For Social Work Application Essay For Social Work Secondary Application Essay Med School Admission Essay For Med School Application Essay For Mcgill University Medical College Admission Essay Application Essay For Medical School Application Essay Medical School Medical School Admission Essay Service Nursing Graduate School Admission Essay Nursing Grad School Admission Essay Essay For School Of Nursing Admission Writing Nursing School Admission Essay Admission Essay Nursing Admission Essay For Nursing School Admission Essay For Nurse Anesthesia Best Nursing Admission Essay College Admission Essay Nursing Graduate Nursing Admission Essay Nursing Admission Essay Help

Supreme Court Continues the A-12 Case Between Government, Boeing and GD

In the late 1980′s the U.S. Navy’s aircraft carriers were equipped with A-6 Intruder and A-7 Corsair II attack aircraft. The Navy wanted to design and build an advanced, stealth aircraft to replace these Vietnam era systems. This led to the A-12 Avenger program that would design and produce a similar aircraft to the U.S. Air Force’s F-117 stealth fighter. The Navy signed a contract with McDonnell Douglas, now part of Boeing (BA), and General Dynamics (GD).

The program though ran into cost and schedule issues and ultimately was cancelled in 1991 by then Defense Secretary Dick Cheney. When the Government terminates a contract it may end up owing the contractors money or be paid back for some of the cost. In this case the Government claimed that the two contractors owed due to non-performance while GD and McDonnell-Douglas claimed that they were owed for work done but not paid for yet because the contract was ended illegally.

Normally contracts are terminated for convenience which means the books are closed and settled and the contractors received some payment or they are terminated for cause in which case some money may be returned to the Treasury. The two companies claimed that because the contract was cancelled by the Defense Secretary rather then the Contracting Officer proper procedures were not followed. Both they and the Government sued each other. The case has been winding its way through the Federal Court system for almost twenty years.

Almost two years ago a Federal appeals court agreed with the Government that they were owed about $3 billion. The contractors then appealed to the Supreme Court and their case was heard. They claimed that the Government was hindering the case by using the “state secrets” privilege to keep key information from being heard by the courts in their defense. The Justice Department said that due to the stealth technology involved in the aircraft’s design and manufacture that it needed to be protected.

The Supreme Court ruled Monday that the contractors were right. They did not, though, rule in their favor but threw the case back to the appeals court for a re-hearing. The high court said clearly that the Navy could not receive the money while they used the “state secrets” rule to prevent the release of information.

This means that further hearings and trials may be ahead in this case. It is one of the longest running and largest contract disputes between contractors and the Defense Department and does not seem to be ending any time soon.

Photo from DaveReichert’s Flickr photostream.

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Defense Department Reiterates Stand on C-17 Production

The C-17 transport has been in production now for almost twenty years and forms the backbone of the U.S. Air Force’s strategic lift. It replaced the Cold War era C-141 aircraft and has been built by Boeing (CA) at their plants in Long Beach, CA and St. Louis, MO. The Air Force actually possesses more C-17′s then originally planned because Congress has been adding them to the budget for the last few years. In 2010 the new Obama Administration did not request any further production of the system but Congress added them and the President did not follow through with a veto.

The 2011 defense budget also contained no C-17 procurement and this has been met with a better reception by Congress in general. There are still those Senators and Representatives from California, Missouri and Kansas who would like to see more aircraft built. They are certainly being used, but the Air Force and DoD argue that the money could be spent on more important parts of the defense budget. There are also concerns that when the Congress adds aircraft they do not necessarily fund the support which takes money out of the budget as well.

The Long Beach plant will close when production of the aircraft ends which would be a big blow to the local economy.

Despite Congress’ better attitude this year the Department must have some concerns as they released a strongly worded article yesterday detailing the reasons why no more aircraft are needed. This reads in part “..defense officials agreed with the subcommittee’s leaders, Sens. Thomas Carper and John McCain, that the C-17, in addition to the C-5, has been critical to airlift in and out of Iraq and Afghanistan. However, they said, the military’s current fleet of 223 C-17s and 111 C-5s is more than enough airlift capability for years to come.” It also contains a threat as last year that the President “.. has promised to veto any legislation that provides for more C-17s.”.

Does that mean there will be no more U.S. orders for the C-17? It might, and it might not. Congress is loathe to end programs like this that are not only successful, used and provide several hundred jobs across the U.S. Boeing certainly would like to keep the line going. The defense budget looks like it may make it to the floor of the Senate and House without C-17. That allows floor amendments and the conference committee to add the transports. If the Congressional leadership is disciplined it may end up without additions.

The other concern is how well Congress believes Obama will veto the bill over a few billion spent on the C-17. If they don’t think he will in the end as happened last year then the aircraft quantity may increase.

Photo from TMWolf Flickr photostream.

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

WTO Report on Airbus Subsidies Roils Tanker Battle Further

Yesterday the formal report by the World Trade Organization (WTO) on their investigation of complaints by the U.S. Government and Boeing (BA) that EADS (EADS:P) and its subsidiary, Airbus, received illegal subsidies was released. The WTO did not support all aspects of the complaint but did say that launch aid provided by European governments to the airliner company was wrong. This launch aid was normally in the provision of low interest loans that were only paid back once the sale of the aircraft became profitable. The aid was considered illegal export subsidies.

U.S. politicians supportive of Boeing’s bid for the new KC-X aerial tanker for the Air Force seized on the report to aid their quest to have EADS bid either rejected or adjusted to reflect the addition of the illegal subsidies. The Pentagon has clearly stated several times in the past that as part of their source selection process they cannot and will not take into account the loans and other aid.

Congress recently passed legislation in the House that is an attempt to force the Defense Department to do that. The Senate needs to also vote on it and it will then move to a discussion of whether the DoD will follow that requirement.

The WTO said that without this aid the company would not have been in as good financial shape as it has been and could not afforded to develop some products — including the superjumbo airliner A380. The WTO may force the company to pay back some of the money, or allow the U.S. to impose tariffs on European goods.

The WTO did rule though that other aid the company received such as tax breaks or infrastructure support rose to the level of illegal subsidies. EADS and the European governments will appeal the case back to the WTO and are waiting to hear about their counter complaint. In this they are claiming that the money Boeing received from the U.S. military for Research & Development (R&D) amounts to illegal subsidies as well as it helped develop their commercial aircraft. That ruling may be announced before the end of the month.

The KC-X program is now on its third attempt to buy a new tanker to replace the aging KC-135 aircraft. The WTO ruling will make it easier for Boeing’s supporters to claim EADS is undercutting prices and causing the source selection process to be even more difficult. It also allows for a protest by either company if they lose and will motivate Congress to interfere even more.

The situation has been caused by the lack of aircraft manufacturers in the world. Really only Boeing and EADS may bid on the contract. With the demise of McDonnell Douglas in the Nineties there exists only one U.S. source. Awarding a sole source contract to Boeing will be difficult and the Air Force wants at least a modicum of competition.

Further delays seem inevitable.

Photo from Monica’s Dad’s flickr photostream.

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Rolls-Royce To Build Engines For U.S. Training Aircraft

T45 goshawk engine contractThe U.S. Defense Department awarded a contract to Rolls-Royce to deliver F405-RR-401 jet engines. The $90 million contract will be to build the engines for the T-45 jet trainer as well as perform maintenance and logistics support for them. The bulk of the production will occur at Rolls-Royce’s Indiana facilities with support occurring wherever the Navy needs it.

The T-45 Goshawk is a modern, singled engine two seat trainer. Based on a BAE design it was originally manufactured by McDonnell Douglas in the United States before that company was acquired by Boeing. Over two hundred of the aircraft have been delivered to the Navy and they are able to conduct carrier landings and training.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/flyingsinger/ / CC BY 2.0
Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Aero India International Show Attracts Fighter Bidders

The six companies that submitted proposals for India’s new Medium Multi-role Combat Aircraft (MMRCA) contract will all be in attendance at the Aero India International Show. The Economic Times reports that the competitors for the potential $10 billion contract will be at the show along with a host of other U.S. and European companies. Boeing, Lockheed, EADS, SAAB, Dassault and MiG all submitted proposals for the program. The theme of the show will be business activity between Indian and foreign companies. This contract is now one of the largest for tactical aircraft out for bid, and the companies will be touting their wares at the show.

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

U.S Air Force Buys 15 C-17 Aircraft from Boeing

The BBC News reports that the U.S. Air Force awarded Boeing a contract to build 15 C-17 transport aircraft. The contract is worth almost $3 billion. The Air Force had been debating whether to buy any more C-17 but Congress provided the funds for these aircraft. The C-17 and C-5 fleet has been used a great deal supporting operations in Iraq and Afghanistan. The C-17 line was building some FMS aircraft for Qatar, UK and Canada but could see an end to production in the near future. This lot will continue the production for several more months.

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Looks like Australia will go with the JSF

Australia had being going back and forth on wanting the F-22 instead of the JSF. China, I am sure, has a lot to do with this. According to this story, the decision has been made to go with the F-35. America has a law preventing the export of the F-22, but Australia had asked for it anyway. There was some desire from the USAF to sell it, as every FMS sale lowers the price and the Air Force would like some more. The only way that is going to happen is to get it cheaper. So it will have to be seen if any sales overseas are made. Certainly Australia and the UK would be the prime customers for the F-22.

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Australia cuts bait

The Australian government decided after all to go ahead with the purchase of the F/A-18 to gap fill until the JSF is available. An article is here. The new more liberal government had discussed canceling the contract to save money. Now they claim they have been able to reduce the total cost, so it is worthwhile. See a previous article here. Read more

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

Boeing continues to support KC-10 fleet while waiting on KC-X

The US Air Force gave Boeing a $307 m contract to continue logistics support for the most modern tankers in their fleet, the KC-10. See the St. Louis Business Journal here for more. Boeing and EADS continue to wait for the US Air Force to come to some decision on the KC-X program. If the Air Force had invested in more KC-10 aircraft in the 80′s, when there certainly was an ability to buy them, there would not be the issues today. The KC-X arose out of the ill-fated plan to lease KC-767 aircraft from Boeing in 2001-2002. This collapsed under ethical issues. Now six years later there is still not a replacement aircraft.

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

McDonnell Douglas awarded Navy Harpoon contract

The US Navy awarded Boeing component McDonnell Douglas a $74 M contract for anti-ship missile Harpoon III development. See Forbes here for more information. The Harpoon is one of only two successful anti-ship systems developed in the west. The other being the French designed and produced Exocet. For more on the Harpoon system see this at Wikipedia.

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter

>