purchase compendium
business homework helper
executive brief writing service michigan
dissertation literature review services
freelance sports writers wanted
purchase cover letter
custom writers essay service
inexpensive brief writing services
college essay on community service
where can you buy research papers
cover letter for customer service in a airline
ghost writers for hire
help with managerial accounting homework
tips for getting essays done
eating disorders essay
resume cv writing services
do you need a ghostwriter
math homework help free tutor
buy essays now
custom printed note paper
essay transition help
powerpoint broadcast service sharepoint 2010
case study interview help
help with dissertation questions
help with writing skills children
professional resume writing services ratings
research proposal writers uk
buying a dissertation uk
cheap college term papers
help in dissertation
i don39t want to write my college essays
which cv writing service review
homework help geometry free
assignment service
dissertation help co uk review
becoming a professional ghostwriter
resume services indianapolis
how much is a ghostwriter
medical school personal statement editing service
best curriculum vitae writing services in new york city
homework helpers books
science homework help high school
help with dissertation methodology
buy research papers writing service
resume writers las vegas
resume writing services austin tx
yorku essay help
community service definition essay
write my research paper for me for free
buy college football tickets
have someone write my paper
synopsis writing services prices
resume writing services dubai
letter of recommendation help me
get paid to write articles
free online will writing service
get someone to do my homework
cv services in dubai
homework help howard county library
java assignment help free
professional resume writers perth wa
cost for resume service
is it safe to buy essay online
essays help online
write my essay uk
website content writers uk
free online help with physics homework
buy book reviews on amazon
homework help india
buy custom business plan
case study borderline personality disorder
college essay to buy
assignment writing services india
need help with statistics homework
english essay help services
reviews for resume writing services
hiring a writer for website
do essays get italicized
buy cheap tissue paper
buy online essays uk
freelance writers wanted india
homework help sites in india
best outline writers
write my assignment dublin
custom essay station creative solutions
help with homework maths
professional cv services reviews
outline editing service
resume examples customer service manager
essay questions about community service
essay writer uk review
jet essay help
write my paperrs.org
assignment service marketing
best college application essay service
resume writer des moines ia
accounting resume writing services sydney
has anyone tried essay writing service
uk custom essays review
homework helpline philadelphia
homework helpster grade 3
buy paper
professional synopsis and synopsis writing services
is buying an essay safe
research proposal writing service uk
case customer gartner show study
help with writing a nonfiction book
film studies essay help
help me i need to write an essay
live online essay help
help write a digest
top letter of recommendation writing services uk
custom paper pads
i have no motivation to write my essay
cv key skillsexamples for customer service
help with homework online chat
why is community service important essay
book harry order phoenix potter review
custom paper plate printing
adsiedit write serviceprincipalname
get motivation to write an essay
letter of recommendation help denver
literature review on self help group
best letter of recommendation writing services for teachers
write my letter of recommendation
online help with writing an essay
social psychology homework help
nursing synopsis help
college report writing service
resume writing services nassau county ny
cv writing services in durban
proposal writing services
average cost of resume writing services
buy paper bags melbourne
get paid for your essays
resume writing services 2013
customs and courtesies essay
any good essay writing services
cv help san diego
professional resume writing service dubai
music homework help ks3
resume writers for fashion industry
primary homework help co uk war blitz
top professional digest writing services
help for dissertation writing
best synopsis writing service in dubai
help me make a thesis statement
literature review help
case study nervous system disorder
professional cv services belfast
write my essay wikipedia
i need help writing a compare and contrast essay
free websites for homework help
english coursework help a level
need homework help
buy papers please
best online homework help
i need help on my homework maplestory
resume professional writers canada
custom papers
help with conspectuss
case study on oppositional defiant disorder
business plan writers
help writing papers for college
cv writers in kent
help writing a research paper outline
freelance writer rates south africa
how critical thinking help in everyday life
writers services agreement
personal statement to get a job
financial accounting homework help free
custom research papers writing
how to write my paper in apa style
college essay editing service
creative writing online help
buy essay papers on line
custom term papers and essays
personal statement help sheet
professional ghostwriting services
freelance writers denver
help with math homework for free
ghost writers for hire california
business plan writers in chicago
what is the best essay service
quickbooks statement writer 2012 manual
professional resume writers in dubai
buy graduation speeches
resume writing services newcastle
free online help with essays
ways to help with homework
cheap college research papers
uk cheap essay
write my report
custom papers online
help with paperwork palm desert
get paid to write articles uk
research proposal on quality customer service
a manual for writers of research papers theses and dissertations free download
big y homework helpline online
free help with math homework problems

The United Kingdom’s SDSR Defence Review – identifying real options for change

July 22, 2010 by
Filed under: Editorial, Syndicated Industry News 
The United Kingdom's SDSR Defence Review - identifying real options for change

The Strategic Defence and Security Review (or SDSR) underway within the UK Ministry of Defence has as its aim a full review of UK commitments, force structures and resourcing.

What started as a Defence green paper under the previous Labour Administration has entered full-blown review territory and following the extent of the UK deficit being revealed is being conducted to achieve all of the above with a substantial reduction in funding.

Given the Sir Humphrey response to political requests for cuts in departmental spending, "come up with three options of which one is completely unpalatable and the other two on close examination are the same". One would expect the reduction in resources to be of the 10-15% level rather than the 20-25% level mooted.

However, it is often been unofficially acknowledged that MoD was able to use it's accounting regime in such as way as to squeeze an extra billion out of budget, so any real cuts also need to encompass the lack of manoeuvre room for budgetary games.

The SDSR or SDR as some are referring to it in shorthand is in effect a 'Strategic Deficit Review' as much as a Strategic Defence Review. In addition the MoD case is due to be sent to Cabinet Office (assuming the successor DOPC structure) and thence to the Star Chamber for execution by the PM and Chancellor.

Unlike many earlier Reviews, it could be suggested that this one cannot result in a salami-slicing approach where in effect each of three armed services is given a number and their cloth is cut accordingly - a couple of tanks here, a frigate there and so forth. One apocryphal example of this was in 1990 where a group were directed to save a few hundred million and had a couple of hours to do to support the Minister. The exercise ended up with harassed officials looking for a Program closest to the number, in this case night vision. Following the war in the Gulf of 1991, the shortfall identified was in - night vision,

The SDSR review process needs to move away from optimising the British Army to re-fight the 1991 or 2003 Iraq war, the Navy the Falklands war of 1982 and the RAF the glories of Operation Desert Fox.

The future will not be like the past.

However, a little lateral thinking could go a long way. The hardest thing to cut in terms of actually doing it and realizing a fast return on the balance sheet are personnel numbers. This is the reason the equipment Program (invariably requiring government to spend on outside goods and services)

The number one challenge for the MoD is the nuclear deterrent. Renewal of the four Vanguard Class SSBN's plus the Trident warheads comes with a price tag in the order of some £20 billion ($30 US). However a clear alternative to designing a new submarine would be to build additional Astute Class hunter/killer submarines and forgo Trident for a nuclear tipped Tomahawk torpedo. Whilst lacking the range and having some vulnerability to intercept let's not forget that this is a political weapon primarily and if used and if only 1 in 4 hit the target it would still be a very high order of 'effect'.

Additionally, a force of Astute SSN/BN submarines would offer flexibility 100% availability as at least one would always be at sea.

For industry, a lengthened Astute Program would offer greater efficiencies (each successive boat being cheaper to build) and greater ease of maintenance with a single design being in service.

The second order question regarding large, expensive equipment programs already committed to is how to get the results of the balance sheet without risking contract termination - which would be devastating to the Defence industry.

Eurofighter could be re-rolled for service on the new aircraft carriers under construction absorbing some of the tranche 3 commitment and again offering basic commonality of airframe for manned aerial effect.
Part of the tranche 3 commitment could be sold on to another government with Saudi Arabia topping the list of obvious parties whom would be interested. Clearly this approach would end UK interest in JSF which is in the test stage, though prior to production.

Next on the list is some clever thinking regarding the carriers themselves. A few years ago there was discussion of the French ordering one of the designs as a second ship to work alongside the unhappy nuclear Charles de Gaulle vessel in some kind of 'euro carrier capability'

Why not sell the first of class overseas ? First of class vessels often are a learning curve and so why not get the first vessel off the balance sheet and enjoy better quality 2nd and 3rd vessels and realize some cost savings. In terms of whom would purchase, the Russian aircraft carrier was touted to the Indian and Chinese Navies. At the time of the Falklands conflict HMS Hermes was due to be sold to India and ultimately was as the Vikrant. that vessel must be close to the end of it's operational life for example.

The Royal Air Force I would suspect could be hard pressed to articulate why the Tornado GR4 is still needed in a period of austerity given that a number of the aircraft have been flown to the edge of their lifespan. A navalised Eurofighter also negates sadly the Harrier jump-jet. If only JSF was not bedeviled by the ITAR waiver issues with the US and inevitable cost-escalation. In terms of supply chain and excluding Eurofighter why does the RAF need so many stations ? Time for fast consolidation.

The Royal Navy also needs to forgo a Naval Base with Portsmouth the obvious choice. Although a deal of service accommodation was built there recently the fact is that Portsmouth real estate is far more valuable and there is a fundamental force protection issue given how busy the waterways are around the Solent.

In terms of the surface fleet the most pressing need is to move forward with a replacement Program for the Type-23 Frigate which is modular, small, punchy and plentiful in numbers. Hopefully the river class vessels can offer a better model than a cut down type 42 for the 'c1' capability need.

Major new investment in UAV's should be the winner. A smaller frigate should have dedicated UAV ASW capability reducing the need for Nimrod from the RAF.

Whilst sad, thinking the unthinkable as Herman Kahn once put it is no longer a luxury which can be pursued in the Club room or mess. It is essential and is needed right now.

- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone

Location:In a galaxy far, far, away...

Technorati Tags:
, ,

Read the original post here.


Feel free to leave a comment...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!

You must be logged in to post a comment.